What Is the Grace of God?
Mark
Mullins
Use
the following outline to go directly to key topics in this study:
Introduction
Grace
in the Old Testament
Grace
in the Gospels and Acts
Grace
in the New Testament Letters
Grace
in the Book of Galatians
Grace
in the Book of Romans
Recommended
Reading
Introduction
Grace
is one of the central doctrines of Christianity.
If we do not understand grace, we will have great difficulty
understanding scripture.
Many who leave Christianity do so because of a poor understanding
of what God has done for us through His grace.
There
is no English word that adequately describes this concept.
Early English translators rendered the Greek word charis
as gracea translation that has remained until
today. Grace had a certain meaning in sixteenth-century
England that it does not have today, and even that meaning is
inadequate to describe the concept of Gods grace.
What,
then, is the grace of God?
I will attempt to answer that question by looking at
several terms and concepts throughout scripture.
The term charis in New Testament Greek has no
direct equivalent in Old Testament Hebrew, but we will look
at several parallel concepts.
More important than the academic knowledge, however,
is the spiritual experience of grace in our lives.
I plan to have ample opportunity to develop that as well.
Most
studies of grace center almost exclusively on the book of Romans,
with a passing glance at the book of Galatians.
I want to devote significant time to these two books,
but I think they represent only a small fraction of the Bibles
teaching on grace. Thus
I will not place the emphasis there as much as many writers
do. Many Christians
assume that Gods grace is only present in the New Testament,
but I hope to demonstrate that it has been present from the
beginning.
Many
Christians believe that Gods grace is not present in the
Old Testament. But
the careful reader will see that Gods grace abounds there,
no matter which shade of meaning we might look for.
Over and over, Yahweh is described in terms such as these:
merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and abounding
in steadfast love and faithfulness (Ex. 34:6-7, 2 Chr.
30:9, Neh. 9:17, Ps. 86:15, Jon. 4:2).
Four
words. This
formula helps to define the concept of Gods grace with
four words. The
word for mercy here is rachum, the word for
grace is hen, the word for steadfast
love is hesed, and the word for faithfulness
is emeth. Together,
these words represent the grace of God as described in the Hebrew
Bible.
Rachum
describes the compassion or mercy of God, and is never used
to describe a human being.
It represents His willingness to forego the punishment
that we deserve because of our sin.
Hen
is the Hebrew word that is translated as charis (grace)
in the Greek translation of the Old Testament.
It is often translated favor in English Bibles.
A person who enjoys another persons hen
is able to interact socially with another person because of
his/her status or relationship.
In the case of humans enjoying the hen of God,
this status is totally undeserved.
Perhaps
the most profound word in this group is hesed. It is translated in several ways: lovingkindness,
love, goodness, steadfast love,
and others. It
is difficult to translate precisely because it is so all-encompassing.
This word describes the love of God, unfailing, unending,
and unlimited. This word is seldom used to describe the love of human beings,
and when it is, it indicates an extraordinarily good relationship.
This word is usually translated as agape in the
Greek Old Testament.
The
fourth word is emeth, a word translated truth
or faithfulness.
It reflects the unending reliability and stability of
Gods loving relationship to humankind.
These
four words together help to illustrate the Old Testament concept
that I am calling grace.
When this formula is used in Exodus 34:6-7, it is uttered
by God after Moses cut two new tablets of stone to replace the
two he had broken when he observed the nations wickedness
in worshiping the golden calf.
The implication is that Israel deserves to die or to
forfeit Gods protection.
By all rights, God should have selected a new people.
Yet by re-writing His covenant on the new tablets, Yahweh
is proclaiming Himself as a God of grace.
Manifestations
of grace in the Old Testament . In a time when
the entire world was wicked, Noah found hen in the eyes
of Yahweh (Gen. 6:8).
This favor was partially deserved, for Noah did not walk
in the immoral ways of the rest of the world.
Yet Gods favor is actually undeserved, as becomes
clear with Noahs life in the years after the flood.
Noah did not find Gods favor through hs perfection,
but through his devotion to obeying God.
When
Jacob and Esau are reunited after years of estrangement (Gen.
33:1-17), Jacob tries to secure his brothers hen
by sending many gifts.
But Esau points out that the true hen is the sight
of his brothers face.
The gifts were an unnecessary part of acquiring Esaus
favor. Here the
grace of God is illustrated through the reaction of Esau.
The
law of Moses is a system by which grace is dispensed.
The book of Leviticus details many different types of
sacrifices that undeservedly bring forgiveness of various sins,
intentional and unintentional.
Yet the heart of penitence is the most important element
in the Old Testament doctrine of forgiveness of sin.
The
gospels we have today are relatively late New Testament books. Most or all of Pauls letters were written before any
of the gospels. Before
the gospels were written, stories about Jesus life, teachings,
death, and resurrection circulated among the churches by word
of mouth.
When
the gospels were written, the church was beginning to recognize
the importance of written documents to the preservation of the
church. The evangelists who wrote the gospels sought to portray Him
as, among other things, a manifestation of Gods grace. The concept of grace had already been extensively taught by
Paul and others before this time.
Matthew
and Mark do not use the word charis at all, but both
portray Jesus as an agent of both physical and spiritual healing.
The story of the Gerasene demoniac in Mark 5 is one of
the most poignant examples.
Jesus, through the grace He dispensed, was able to transform
this man completely and make him a viable human being.
The text certainly portrays this gift as undeserved and
prompted by compassion.
The parables of the kingdom (Matthew 13, Mark 4) paint
a picture of the nature of a world impacted by grace.
Johns
gospel uses the word charis four times in his introduction
(1:1-18). This
book is perhaps the last New Testament book to be written (around
the year 95), and the writer takes a contemplative approach
to Jesus story.
In reflecting on the utter significance of His existence,
John mentions the incarnation (the word became flesh,
1:14), and describes this situation as full of grace and
truth. Through
Him we receive grace upon grace (1:16), because only Jesus is
the source of grace and truth (1:17). In
the narrative that follows, John never again uses the term charis;
but his entire book is, in many ways, an illustration of the
grace and truth that Jesus exemplifies.
His
grace enables Him to change water to wine to enable a host to
avoid a social faux pais (ch. 2).
He changes the life of a religious leader in ch. 3 and
a shady woman in ch. 4in both cases with a dose of grace
and truth. In ch.
5, he heals through His grace; in ch. 6 He feeds through His
grace. The list
could go on and on.
Luke
and Acts employ the word charis a number of times. Sometimes, the word for Luke indicates favor, much as the Hebrew
word hen (Acts 2:47, 7:10, 7:46, 24:27, 25:3). Other times, however, he is referring to the grace of God.
In Luke 1:30, Mary finds grace (favor) with God, and
the boy Jesus later finds the same favor with both God and humankind
(2:40, 52). When
Jesus begins to preach, the people are amazed at His words of
grace (4:22). This
first impression of the people serves as an introduction to
Jesus earthly ministry.
Soon after this, He begins healing people and changing
their lives.
In
the book of Acts, Stephen is said to be full of both grace and
power (6:8). Barnabas
goes to Antioch to visit a group of new believers and immediately
sees Gods grace there (11:23).
Indeed, grace seems to be a gift from God that enables
people to do effective ministry (4:33). Grace also brings credibility to Gods message, by whatever
means necessary (14:3).
At the Jerusalem Council, Peter affirms that all are
saved solely through the grace of God (15:11).
Conclusion.
The grace of God is more implicit that explicit in the gospels
and Acts, but the intended readers of these books were well-acquainted
with the notion of a gracious God and would see ample evidence
for this in the evangelists stories about Jesus and the
early church. There
they would find confirmation for the doctrine of grace as presented
by earlier sources such as the letters of Paul.
In short, Gods steadfast love continues in the
person of Jesus Christ.
Hebrews.
The writer of this document begins his book by describing
the superiority of Jesus to other spiritual powers such as angels.
How He gained this superiority, however, is through His suffering, His self-abasement.
In 2:9, the writer notes that Jesus was made lower
than the angels for a short while, but is now crowned
with glory and honor because of His suffering and death, so
that by the grace of God He might taste death for everyone.
Gods grace allowed Jesus to die in our place.
The effects of this event are a gift from God.
As
a result, Christians are able to approach the throne of
grace (4:16). Here
the concept of grace is paired with the concept of power and
authority symbolized by a throne.
For the writer of Hebrews, Gods grace seems to
be connected closely with power.
In 10:29, the writer refers to the outrage of the Spirit
of grace when believers spurn the Son of God by continuing
in evil after being sanctified in the truth.
This is an interesting reference because it refers to
divine anger with regard to sinthe opposite of what many
people think of when they think of grace.
1-2
Peter. These letters use the term grace to reflect maturity
in a Christians life and ministry.
In 1 Peter 2, the NRSV translates the word charis
as credit (v. 19) and approval (v. 20).
This is in the context of Peters household codea
set of principles by which each segment of society should live
in a given culture. Specifically,
this comment comes in the instructions to slaves.
Slaves in that culture do better to suffer for doing
right than to suffer for doing wrong.
In doing the former, these slaves reflect Jesus
sacrifice and Gods grace. Thus grace here reflects a maturity that does not dwell on
self.
Peter
writes that we should be good stewards of grace (4:10), and
we should be mindful to accept the true grace of God
(5:12)which implies that false concepts of grace are being
advocated among Peters hearers. In 2 Peter 3:18, the last verse of the letter, the writer encourages
us to grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and
Savior Jesus Christa reference to growth and maturity.
Pauls
Letters. Paul adopts the word grace to describe
Gods response to sinful people the unmerited salvation
of humans through Jesus Christ.
This use of the term is probably coined by Paul, whose
letters are among the earliest written of our New Testament
books. Other New Testament writers, aware of Pauls use of this
term, use it in similar ways, but never with the degree of emphasis
that Paul gives it. Studies
of grace usually center on Pauls letters to the Romans
and the Galatians, but the concept receives emphasis in almost
all his letters.
According
to Paul, grace is uniquely Gods to give (Col. 1:15; Eph.
2:5). Human beings
cannot bestow grace. He
does not distinguish clearly between the grace of God
and the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ.
Grace is liberating and freeing to peoples spiritual
lives. God is not
obligated to save us, nor does He have a psychological need
to do so. Grace
is the only way we can be justified before God.
God gives salvation to humankind through His grace.
Salvation in Paul most often refers to salvation in this
life, with a promise of eternal life to come.
Paul
often uses the word grace as a shorthand way of
referring to the entire Christ event (Titus 2:11).
In fact, Paul sees grace as the opposite of sin, and
as a sinless human, Jesus epitomized grace as He walked the
earth. Grace has
the power to renew lives and change minds and hearts.
In
the coming weeks, we will look more closely at Pauls concept
of grace, and how it relates to the concepts found in the rest
of scripture.
Pauls
letter to the Galatians was probably the first New testament
book to be written. Paul
passed through some parts of the province of Galatia on his
first missionary journey.
He established some churches there, but soon after leaving
learns of a situation of intense conflict there.
Paul is angry as he writes this letter.
He even fails to give a
blessing or thanksgiving at the beginning of his letter,
a feature found in virtually all Greek letters.
The effect of this breach of protocol is ominous for
the readers.
Jan
Faver Hailey writes of the Galatian church: Disagreement
exists over spiritual doctrine, intellectual arguments, and
conflict from differing traditions and backgrounds.
But the seldom-noticed conflict that permeates the epistle
is the power struggle which arises out of relationships that
are unequal. Oppression,
coercion, deceptive persuasion, and manipulation are mentioned
more than twenty times in the letter, excluding the works of
the flesh in the vice list of chapter five (and at least half
of those mentioned easily fall in those categories). . . . Paul
is concerned with two groups in the letter.
One group attempted to manipulate, or perhaps coerce,
Gentile Christians into accepting a different gospel
and the other group allowed themselves to be so compelled
(Neither Male Nor Female, in Essays on Women
in Earliest Christianity, ed. C. Osburn [College Press,
1993]).
Paul
begins his letter with a narration of his own history in the
church (1:11-2:14). Paul
has a couple of goals in mind as he writes this section. First,
he wants his readers to know that he did not get his gospel
from the establishment in Jerusalem, but from God
Himself. Second, he wants to paint a picture of Gods grace
in his own life. At
key points in his story (1:15, 2:9, 2:21), Paul brings up the
idea of grace.
For
Paul in this letter, grace is linked very closely with freedomthe
freedom that all persons have in Jesus Christ, regardless or
race, gender, or social class.
It also indicates Gods freedom.
God is free in giving salvation because He is not obligated
by some inner necessity or by the moral merits of people to
do what He does with sinners.
This can only be accounted for by grace.
As
a result, grace brings justification to humankind despite the
fact that not a single one of us deserves it.
Justification is an act of God alone; it cannot be achieved
by a legal system of any kind.
Those who want to justify themselves by law have fallen
away from grace (5:4).
The
Galatian people were simple thinkers, and Paul is uncharacteristically
harsh with them because this is the language they understand.
They have not accepted the power of Gods grace,
and they have replaced that grace with a legal approach to their
relationship with God.
To Paul, that is the worst thing that could happen in
a church.
Background.
Romans is Pauls Magna Carta on the subject
of grace. It is Pauls longest biblical letter and contains the
most complete statement of Christian theology found in scripture.
Many scholars believe that, unlike the other letters
of the New Testament, Romans is not written to address
some specific situation of the hearers of the letter. Rather, they believe, Paul is writing a letter of introduction
to a church that has not met him, in the hopes that they will
support him financially in his proposed mission to Spain (15:23).
I
believe that this is one important reason that Paul wrote Romans,
but I believe that he is also indirectly addressing a situation
in Romes church as well.
In 51-52 a.d.,
the emperor Claudius expelled all the Jewsincluding
Jewish Christiansfrom the city of Rome.
Two years later, they were allowed to return.
Since the church there was probably made up of both Jews
and gentiles from the beginning, such a decree would have an
enormous impact on the churchs size, its makeup, and its
leadership. Jewish
believers who returned after two years found a church that had
a much more gentile flavor.
Thus it seems only natural, in a letter universally agreed
to have been written in the mid 50s, that Paul would emphasize
that Jews and Gentiles alike are equally guilty before God,
and equally dependent on His grace (ch. 1-3).
Thesis.
Pauls thesis statement occurs in 1:16-17: For
I am not ashamed of the good news; it is the power of God for
salvation to everyone who has faith, to the Jew first and also
to the Greek. He
proceeds to describe the things that separate human beings from
God. Humans in general are guilty of many sins (1:18-32).
At this point, pious Jews in the audience probably feel
quit smug, so Paul addresses the sins of the Jews in chapter
2. A major sin
of theirs is being judgmental toward others (2:1-16).
Even if certain Jews are not guilty of this, they are
all guilty of something that separates them from God
(2:17-3:8). Therefore,
there is no reason to have spiritual pride and a feeling of
superiority because of ones Judaism.
To illustrate his point, Paul weaves together quotations
from a number of Psalms to form a poem that illustrates humankinds
utter hopelessness before God (3:9-18).
With
this point established, Paul begins to talk about Gods
gracious offer of universal salvation, which comes through nothing
more than faith in Him (3:21-4:25).
We must not boast of our own righteousness, because this
might lead us to believe that we earned it rather than receiving
it by His grace. Even
Abraham, considered to be the father of the Jews,
was justified because he believed in God.
Implications.
Paul then plays out the implications of this theology.
We are justified by Gods grace through the
conduit of faith (ch. 5).
Thus faith is not a work, a minimum requirement, a burden
on people, but merely an expectation that God is willing and
able to do what He has promised.
Our baptism thus becomes the symbol of our covenant relationship
with God, in which we are dedicating our entire lives to being
more like Him and less like our dead selves (ch. 6).
This creates a struggle in everyones lifeincluding
Paulsbetween good and evil (ch. 7).
Yet those who are in Christ have nothing to worry, because
Gods promise to them is life (ch. 8).
Exhortation.
Paul then outlines his view of how the church at Rome should
respond to Gods universal salvation (12:1-15:13).
The church and its individual members should conform
itself to the image of Christs body by sacrificing their
own bodies. Thus
the church becomes the body of Christ on earth (ch. 12). This means good citizenship in the world (13:1-7) and a spirit
of love in the Christian community (13:8-14).
Most of all (given the situation in Rome), Christians
should not judge one another because of differences in belief,
practice, and outlook on life (ch. 14).
Yet everyone should be aware of the weaknesses of others
and do their best to keep them from stumbling.
Finally, Christians should defer to one another for the
sake of the church as a whole (ch. 15).
Conclusion.
Pauls message in Romans describes Gods grace as
the only means of salvation for any human being.
No amount of good can cause one to earn ones justification
before God. Our
membership in the church, our hope for salvation, and even the
good things we do today are possible only because God is gracious
to us. Yet this
letter outlines the human response to grace like no other letter.
Our response to Gods infinite grace should be to
display grace in our own lives.
TOP
Recommended
Reading
Very
few academic books exist strictly on the topic of grace. One good treatment is Thomas Odens The Transforming
Power of Grace (Abingdon, 1993).When studying grace, it
is always good to have a good rhetorical commentary on the book
of Romans, such as Luke T. Johnsons Reading Romans
(Crossroad, 1993). Two devotional books on grace have recently
been released. Both
are excellent, both are based mostly on the book of Romans,
and both are now available in both hardcover and audio cassette
editions. Max Lucados
In the Grip of Grace is among his best books.
Each chapter in the book is a meditation on a succeeding
section of Pauls letter to the Romans. Philip Yanceys Whats So Amazing About Grace
explores grace at the practical-application level, and challenges
the church to better live up to its calling as the dispenser
of Gods grace to the world.